Rayhana Sultan on October 21, 2012
very badly judged.

Amogha Dalvi on October 24, 2012
the transition from the english song to the antaraa.. MAN.. she blew me
away! Each time I hear it I find something that gives me goosebumps!
Thankyou guys

Shaveei Harvind on October 26, 2012
out of this world...

Shaveei Harvind on November 01, 2012
i am addicted to this song.

Sandeep Chowdhury on November 07, 2012
She was good to start but she lost her pitch when she started with Kahiye
tohh, kahiye toh aasmaan ko.

Arjun Kapur on November 08, 2012
Freaking. Crazy.

Aasim Arahan on November 14, 2012
i reversed tht part thrice to compel myself tht she hadnt lost
it...!though the end with the drums pacified it and wr the best.!!

Yahookudi on November 14, 2012
Breathtaking! Greater than the original! Wish they didn't have the English
though!

technofunky on December 06, 2012
Beautiful, just beautiful.

bigpurple100 on December 06, 2012
coke studio kicks ass!

Shailendra Sen on January 21, 2013
mushkil nahi hai kuch bhi .agar thaan lijiye

jasmine das on February 02, 2013
beautiful rendition..really heart touchin..

9tfy on February 04, 2013
I was skeptical before hearing Monali's version. Beautifully done. And
mann... the arrangement is rocking!

vaibhav dixit on March 12, 2013
Its one of the best cover i've heard... amazing music arrangement..

Zam on March 17, 2013
- When words fall short ! :O

Zam on March 17, 2013
But the transition was amazing. We can't deny this. And also, the singer
proves her versatility wonderfully here. She needs practice to reach
perfection yes, but this track, according to me, has been wonderfully
assembled. I was actually listening to this subtly, while doing my work,
and it struck me when the transition began ! Proof of being a good job !

Nitin Kishore on March 19, 2013
4.10 the best part!!!!!! miss thakur marry me...

ashdhaad on March 19, 2013
Mr. Kale makes a revolution with monali,shruti,shilpa,apeksha n rest of
pepl in it. Hats off..

superautobacs on March 28, 2013
SImply outstanding.beautifully done.

Mohammad Omar on March 30, 2013
AAP meera kaha mana layein , ganaa na gayien especially Urdu one. Your are
simply horrible.

Saurabh Agrawal on April 23, 2013
wat an insult to orignal

Kaushik Guha on April 27, 2013
Nothing is original...its being interpreted by singers as they feel...There
is no one right way..There is many ways to reach heart

Soumyadeep Chakravarty on May 04, 2013
re composing of this music is just worst than hell

Soumyadeep Chakravarty on May 06, 2013
keep your breath to cool your porridge. if anyone wants to show his/her
talent why don't they create their own new composition? here what they are
trying to show that this new arrangement of sound and the singing pattern
is better than the old one this is the complete insult of the original
song?? if you are a real music critic then open your ears or better you
trained your ears. better you listen the original song then think before
comment.

ram2i0 on May 11, 2013
GOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDD STOP IT..HOW CAN YOU DO THIS TO A CLASSIC.

ram2i0 on May 11, 2013
I am also a musician. But you can attempt something like this in your
bathroom may be (i won't event attempt that)...certainly not in coke
studio. I had some regards for coke studio...no more after this.

Ujjwal Singh on May 12, 2013
Really great combination

Tilak Datta on May 16, 2013
youtube is a democratic platform so whether you negatively criticize
anything or you standby whats being uploaded, it shows your commentary on
this video. There is no point in attacking personally about taste and
preference. Write what you feel about the video.

Tilak Datta on May 16, 2013
Don't be sad as you are gifted and all of us here alive!

sudarshan71 on May 18, 2013
Besuri total lack or vocal range a singer such as her should not try dil
cheez etc even the English portions are BAD

safdar majeed on May 18, 2013
really ? I suppose you can do better

Rihab Khan on May 24, 2013
The original is eternal but this is something different all together! W.O.W!

A Zai on June 14, 2013
Armenian from California.love this song. Well sung, love Karsh Kale, and
all these souls are very talented.

Malini Misra on July 02, 2013
v poorly sung

Manav Singh on July 06, 2013
Brilliant music.

Marv3Lthe1 on July 12, 2013
Monali you are a gem

jackhasanewass on July 16, 2013
why should asking for excellence be considered a problem of our society.
asha g possessed undisputed talent and she is great and has set a
benchmark. So if you sing one of her songs you will definitely be compared
with the best. also your argument has a fallacy riding in a Mercedes or
rolls Royce is not the same as traveling in a nano or maruti 800. both are
cars but of a different class, and its human nature if you are treated with
the best you crave more of it and this just doesn't satisfy

ek_tha_KC on July 21, 2013
she rocks!! came here after sawaar loon song in lootera..

Onkar Shirsekar on July 26, 2013
Karsh Kale on Tabla...how epic is that!!!...very well set!!!

Aniket Kulkarni on August 02, 2013
Hit Like if you come to youtube and search for this song :).. Awesome
singing ...

sheetansh kaushik on August 04, 2013
i appreciate the music... i am fascinated by the various projects
undertaken by COKE studio... also i would like to see some more
Folk/Regional music make its way onto such a stage rather than mainstream
songs reinvented...

lovelyethereal on August 20, 2013
like a blast of fresh airrrr

Mistry on August 21, 2013
One word.Chills!!!!!

Shyam Purbiya on August 25, 2013
over panditgiri murkiyo me gaane ki maa bahen karana bakavassssssssssssssss

Huzefa Nasikwalla on September 04, 2013
beautifully sung

tarif haq on September 07, 2013
Monaliiii <3 <3

Hrithik Chatterjee on September 17, 2013
Very well articulated and enumerated Umaji!

mukti nath rai on September 29, 2013
wowowowowowow simply love it..everything is perfect.

Mamoon Fakhrudin on October 08, 2013
destroyed!!

zabeawan on October 11, 2013
everybody did a great job, but it lacked that feel, that addaa that ghazals
need. asha, lata, noor jehan, reshama,rafi kishore and many more never won
an emmy unlike talent less lil wayne and so on and on. KARSH KALE WAS GREAT
THE GIRL COULD HAVE DONE A BETTER JOB.