Viraj Joshi on August 11, 2012
Awesome song! It was going so well before the english part -_- Oh well,
overall it's amazing! :)

jaideep singh on August 11, 2012
wow ... fusion is always . explosive !

jaideep singh on August 11, 2012
love it !!!!

Mukarram husainy on August 11, 2012
Absolutely love this arrangement of a classic song. Monali's voice is
amazing and has a true classic feel and texture to it. Absolutely mind
blowing.

Sambrita Mukherjee on August 12, 2012
really great!i like the concept of coke studio...it's a celebration of
music

AnirbanC on August 12, 2012
Monali has come leaps and bound from her idol days..her harwork is
showing...what control and sustained singing..excpetional...coke studio
hall of fame stuff...

Anshuman Biswas on August 12, 2012
This has to be among the top 5 Coke Studio Tracks.. not only is this track
beautifully arranged.. Monali blows the song to bits.. her tonal control
and pitch/scale are out of this world !!

Jitendra Kumar on August 12, 2012
No words ...m listening this song since yesteryear.n still it's going
on.simply awsum ..thumps up for karsh kale and Monali..

Sakshi Sharda on August 12, 2012
Just beautiful!

Sakshi Sharda on August 12, 2012
Wow! Beautiful interpretation of the classic Dil Cheez Kya Hai. An elegant
disciplined first movement that flows into boundless freedom and back. This
composition is the musical equivalent of flying a kite! :) :)

Avik Ganguli on August 12, 2012
with due respects, this sounds almost un-musical.It feels as if it was all
organised in a hurry

pallav joshi on August 13, 2012
very well sung Monali , but please work upon the pronunciation . It's not
अप ,it's आप :)

Harsh Shah on August 13, 2012
Nice Saarangi and Tabla!!!!

Amit Khosla on August 13, 2012
she is running...there is no expression in the song...music is amazing

avinashr77 on August 13, 2012
Awful rendition of a classic! As someone said no expression what so ever!

abhishek singh on August 13, 2012
dimag ki maa ki aankh kar di bhai sahab. bakwas is too mild a term for this
nonsense

Anupam Choudhari on August 14, 2012
Don't think I have ever seen anyone playing the Tabla standing. Karsh Kale
surely knows how to do things differently.

Jitendra Patel on August 14, 2012
Nice work.

brahmabul on August 14, 2012
Superb yaar. Full points to Monali. The voice modulations were not easy.
One needs to hear this as a new song with no comparison being made with the
original.

abhishek attri on August 15, 2012
Best remix ever!!! You have induced life in the song .amazing work

Koushik Rane on August 15, 2012
She has sung it so beautifully! Some musically uneducated and soulless
people out of utter frustration can only comment negative on dis
track...she is one of the best voices I have heard...n probably the best
voice amongst the rest of the new generation female artists! Guys be honest
to yourselves..! Good job Karsh Kale!

Sandeep sahu on August 15, 2012
Monali.woww.she sounds like a goddess..!! God bless
you...never heard a voice like that before. made my day...!

Ravi Chhabra on August 15, 2012
Looser since you don't find one of the finest compositions of Khayyam Sahab
a good composition and find this outstanding singer to be a degraded
singer, I think u should go back to the planet you belong to because Earth
is definitely not the place. Get your basic English correct "dint expected"
and then comment on anything else, specially when it comes to such
brilliant performances. Shameless!!

jagga007 on August 17, 2012
English part is killer but lot of probs in dil cheez kya hai... the way she
pronounces anjuman is awefull, But musicians played a great role specially
sarangi and tabla.

valent pawar on August 17, 2012
Monali Thakur u rocked it. transaction was grt.loved it.Umrao Jaan
would have never stoped dancinin if it was played in da original movie.
:-D Monali Thakur u cute...!!!!!

joy amin on August 18, 2012
44 dislikes...those ppl never had their mother loving u.they never loved
music...sad souls

Pramod Nambiar on August 19, 2012
:D One of the best songs i hav heard on Coke studio .. !

Massivevibrations Bali on August 20, 2012
goosepumps .

gaurav bhattacharjee on August 20, 2012
lol good one :-D

Siddanth A on August 22, 2012
fantastic monali is mindblowing what harkate ... waaah ...

Sffrntgr on August 23, 2012
really brilliant...

Sushant Kumar on August 25, 2012
Gave me goosebumps. "Mushkil nahin hain kuch bhi agar thaan li jiye". ~
04:37 Brilliant piece.

adil mehboob on August 25, 2012
ooooooooooooooooooooooooosum combination.m from pak nd after ur 1st coke
season mujhay lgta tha tha k tmhara coke studio bakwaas ha but neighbours
is season ma bohat aala music dia ha.kia music director change ho gya ha ya
puranay walay ko aqal aa gai ha

mechstud255 on August 26, 2012
pakis trying too hard..sorry mate..but only this attitude of ur ppl has let
ur country down !!..

Hisham Mohammad on August 29, 2012
oh come on...!!! wat do u think this singer rocks.buuu.!!! go and
listen song MADARI..wat a powerful vocals of both male and female
singer.

Rahul Patil on August 29, 2012
It's time for a change. Replace all Bollywood music directors (except
magicians like ARR) with Karsh Kale, Shankar Tucker!!!!

james20030 on August 29, 2012
Asha ji's voice is way too set in my mind to enjoy this song in any other
voice, but she has done a decent job I think...

Pratik Varma on August 30, 2012
I heard this song many times considering the lineage of the original. My
opinions changed from being dismissive at first to respect for the singer
to frustration at the producers for keeping the vocals a bit muted (compare
to Shilpa's volume in Hallelujah).

MrMalangii on September 06, 2012
I can feel goosebumps as the song progresses.

Amogha Dalvi on September 08, 2012
The song talks about a feeling that people experience universally. Love.
Monali Thankur thankyou for the beautifully conveying that. Thankyou Karsh
Kale.

KARSH KALE on September 10, 2012
the only thing that is cheap is your lame comment.WHat artsits charge is
none of yours or anyone elses business..These are musicians being
musicians...A rare thing to see on Indian TV...

samajder4u on September 10, 2012
Music has no country, no language, no religion...so stop fighting...and
enjoy this beautiful rendition of this awesome song...Monali is
outstanding...

Japneet Singh on September 22, 2012
wow Monali, what a voice you have. You sung different genres very
seamlessly.

Mudra Kumar on September 26, 2012
If this isnt music...then what is my friend?? goosebumps on every second of
the song...just brilliant...karsh kale's tabla was mind-blowing...just the
perfection you need for fusion...and monali thakur's shift from classical
to western just killed it.what an impeccable piece of music!! :D

Vijayavargiya Anshuman on October 06, 2012
very badly sung.

rshcam on October 08, 2012
Good attempt by Monali considering that it is a difficult song to sing.
Composition was ok, could have been better. Or maybe it is just the song -
hard to forget the original and any variations will never impress you.

innotech001 on October 12, 2012
The main problem lies with the speed & arrangement. The song was made for a
courtesan in the movie - therefore you can find a lazy, flirty and sensual
vibe throughout in Ashaji's version - . It was never about the gamakams.
Here Karsh Kale increased the tala (Speed) hence the singer has no room for
relaxed singing, which was essential for the lyrics. Monali is a great
singer, but she struggles to keep up with the pace - when u remix u've to
ensure u don't lose the soul of the composition!

Koushik Rane on October 18, 2012
"NASAL" n "MORE CLASSICAL REQUIRED"..seriously what is wrong with you?

Rayhana Sultan on October 19, 2012
4:10 ... high point :)

Rayhana Sultan on October 21, 2012
You wouldn't say this if you could sing any better. Intellectual criticism
is a good characteristic of human being, baseless criticism is just the
opposite. Pardon I'm no musical guru, but as long as I have the ear to
perceive good music, I have the right express my views and criticism just
as equally as you have the right to criticize :)