Dee Thakore on February 24, 2010
the singer has nice voice almost like talat. very smooth music.

Parag Sankla on February 24, 2010
Yes, Shaminder seems to be inspired by Talat sahab and sings in a soft
melodious voice. The song, as you have rightly mentioned, is very soothing
and pleasing. Like a moonlight night with a pleasant breeze on the beach..

ajitchahal58 on November 17, 2010
oldHMfan,Thankyou ever so much for uploading this song of Bhai Shaminder and Geeta Dutt.Bhai sahib was my (late)husband's youngest uncle.The family was very old and wealthy and it is right Bhai Sahib wanted to sing with Lataji as this was his hobby and not a profession and he did sing with her.Sardul Kwatraji was an excellent musician of his time and later became a family friend.Bhai Shaminder passed away more than two decades ago.I have his picture,he was a very handsome man.

Parag Sankla on November 17, 2010
@ajitchahal58 Ajit ji, many thanks for sharing this information with us.
Please do send us picture of Shamider ji. I have sent a message to you.
please respond. Thanks

MrsRajDhillon on August 02, 2011
Shaminder is my brother.He also acted in afew movies like Aas ka pancchi,Anpadh,dukh bhanjan tera naam,Nanak dukhia sab sansar etc.He was very fond of singing and his dream was to sing with Lataji and he
did sing hindi as well as quite afew punjabi songs with her.she liked him and started calling him Bhayia and tie a rakhi.

rumahale on June 28, 2014
I have enjoyed listening the song and reading very interesting and
informative comments; both singers sound heavenly - rare treat indeed.
Thank you for the best initiative.

TheDeepakp on June 03, 2015
Film cast: Mahipal, Chitra, Manju, Chandrashekhar, Maruti
Singer: Mohammed Rafi, Geeta Dutt, Shaminder
Lyricist: Prem Dhawan
Music Director: Sardul Kwatra
Film Director: Manju