JoyDevivre on August 09, 2008
Please stop this. I've heard both the Spanish and the English versions of
the song and see nothing that could be considered plagiarism. Please
restrain yourself from throwing about such accusations in such a flippant
manner. We're talking about one of the most talented musicians in Hindi
films.

sds1943 on August 19, 2008
Well, all I can say is: I think we both have made our points, let
interested surfers come to their own conclusion now. And perhaps it's
needless to get personal.

MrSigma on August 22, 2008
Even if Himesh spends his entire lifetime, he cannot come up with one song that can match these songs in quality! What is more amazing is to see youngsters gyrating to Rashamaiyya's music (read noise) ?

mehran133 on August 24, 2008
it is a copy of song perhaps by doris day

st471438 on September 09, 2008
She only came in two movies, she is step sister of Madhubala. Her name is
Sangeeta (If i spelled right :) )

nawabshaukat on September 29, 2008
geta dut plus opnayar saab ki gazab naq dhun kanoon main rus ghol diya hay

cactus1762 on October 02, 2008
Well, the first recording of this song (quizas, quizas) was done by Tony
Bavaar and Gordon Jenkins in 1949, and released by Decca Records - well
before 'Babuji'. Originally written and composed by Cuban songwriter
Osvaldo Farres - was a hit since 1947. It is possible that OP nayar was
'inspired' by the FIRST recorded version, and not by Nat King Cole, because
Coles recording first appeared in 1958 - 4 years after 'Babuji'. Doris Day
recorded perhaps much later, in 1964.

cactus1762 on October 02, 2008
Well, the first recording of the song (quizas, quizas) was done by Tony
Bavaar and Gordon Jenkins in 1949, and released by Decca Records - well
before 'Babuji'. Originally written and composed by Cuban songwriter
Osvaldo Farres - was a hit since 1947. It is possible that OP nayar was
'inspired' by the FIRST recorded version, and not by Nat King Cole, because
Cole's recording first appeared in 1958 - 4 years after 'Babuji'. Doris Day
recorded 'perhaps' much later, in 1964.

balleohtere on October 03, 2008
hey thanks man for the insight ! would be great if these versions can be loaded and put up for all to see and compare..would be agreat delight dont u think

Aman Dayani on October 14, 2008
wah janab wah kya baat hai. what a great old song. thanks janab for posting
this old great song. the actress looks zabardast in this great video.
thanks for posting this laajawab song, this is aman dayani from toronto
canada.

sloppyviewer on October 29, 2008
I dont think that is right because I have seen her in more than two movies and her name is.

sloppyviewer on October 29, 2008
her name is shakila not sangeeta and she has starred in more than 2 movies

akarshik on October 29, 2008
Unique & forever song sung by late " Geeta Dutt " Thanks very much for
fantastic upload my friend.

Om V on November 02, 2008
The actress is Suraiyya if I'm not wrong. I was not born in that generation
but still love this song.

Joseph C on November 08, 2008
OP Nayyar was a "Japanese" kind of music director in those days in that He
was just a copycat copying or stealing wonderfully most of his music from
the western world. And the Madras music directors in turn copied Nayyar.
Thankk God, we now have originals like AR RAHMAN, who can not only compose
ANY KIND OF MUSIC, but singing them inimitably as in Jhodha Akbar

DOUBLU123 on November 13, 2008
Well, the first recording of the song (quizas, quizas) was done by Tony Bavaar and Gordon Jenkins in 1949, and released by Decca Records - well before 'Babuji'. Originally written and composed by Cuban songwriter Osvaldo Farres - was a hit since 1947. It is possible that OP nayar was 'inspired' by the FIRST recorded version, and not by Nat King Cole, because Cole's recording first appeared in 1958 - 4 years after 'Babuji'. Doris Day recorded 'perhaps' much later, in 1964.

JoyDevivre on November 18, 2008
Shakeela. Actually I don't blame you - Shakeela had a striking resemblance
to Suraiyya - except Suraiyya had these enormous eyes.

JoyDevivre on November 18, 2008
You have some nerve to say something like this. OP Nayyar was a wonderfully
talented composer. Go check ITWOFS to see how many of OP's songs are
actually copied - very few. And he had such an innate sense for Indian
classical music - even though he wasn't a trained musician.

sds1943 on November 21, 2008
Even that was an 'inspired copy'of the original- like this one!

sds1943 on November 21, 2008
Well said Spanish Caravan. Just a little point though: artists have taken
inspiration from one another. There is nothing wrong with that if they take
permission and acknowledge that. See my comment a couple of years ago.

asdfghj on November 25, 2008
i love this song...but i'm watching the video for the first time, and she
looks kinda possessed.

Zoya Ali Khan on November 29, 2008
does anyone knows from which movie this song is? thanks

69040M on November 30, 2008
one of the best hindi songs

Zoya Ali Khan on November 30, 2008
what is the movies name????????

thrissx3 on December 03, 2008
nice song.. i think aar paar movie ka song hai...

Jayendra Patel on December 23, 2008
Produed by: Guru Dutt( Gita Dutt's name on Posters) Songs by: Majaru
Sultanpori This song's tuned was copy from Net king cole's songs
Cinematography V.K. Murthy Editing by Y. G. Chawhan Produseder

Jayendra Patel on December 23, 2008
movie: Aaar Paar Singer: Gita roy (Gita dutt after this movie) Stars: Guru
Dutt, Shyama Jagdeep, Jagdish Setty,Johnny Walker, Shakila (actress), Bir
Sakuja, Rajendra, Amir Banu, Rashid Khan, M.A. Latif. Music: O.P. Nayyar
Releasd Date:May 21, 1954 Directer: Guru Dutt

registrationannoys on February 28, 2009
Guru Dutt made the ladies swoon back in the day.

ib422000 on March 22, 2009
Which Nat King Cole song was this supposedly copied from, please?

bobagent on March 23, 2009
Its called "quizas quizas quizas". Search it in youtube.

ib422000 on March 23, 2009
You're blessed with the gift of discernment.. and you're absolutely right
about the best is from the past. Even A.R. sometimes jars the soul.

NoMiTaStAR on March 28, 2009
Is very similiar but not equal.

nawabshaukat on April 02, 2009
op nayar aur asha ki ustaad GEETA DUT ki awaz jis say inspired ho kay asha
gee nay gana shuro kya ki jaan leva combination YES I AM TALKING ABOUT THE
ONE AND ONLY OP NAYAR

lemaven on May 05, 2009
Beg to differ - neither is it the same arrangement, neither tempo nor
timbre nor even parallels the octaves. Not a copy ... and in english they
translated it to perhaps ... perhaps ... perhaps.

ConfusedSponge on May 06, 2009
so true.. better than asha ji too

ConfusedSponge on May 06, 2009
is that shakila or shayma dancing?

rajatisrajat on May 06, 2009
simply soul-rendering for a song...

Pravin Patil on May 13, 2009
If you think Lata Ji's voice is squeeky then u should perhaps listen to
''Mogara Phulala'' by Lata Ji. No offence meant. I respect your opinion.

hirlusji on May 18, 2009
which movie???

lizii24 on June 18, 2009
Aar Paar (1954)

hirlusji on June 21, 2009
thanx yaar!!

mamunsum on June 23, 2009
it's just! it's just! fantastic!

zuluruggmen on June 25, 2009
how can one compare Geetaji with Lataji? Both are greater and best at their work so please this comparing game. I admire both of them

Mir Ali on July 02, 2009
Looks like Shakeela.

Debabrata Mohanty on July 18, 2009
Yes it is Shakeela. Her sister Noor, also an actress, was comedian Johny
Walker's wife.

mustafa said on July 24, 2009
very nice song. Now also in malay. R.Azmi " Dari kerana Mata"?? Aaar Paar
1954 film no english subs?? Anybody can help

himsingz on August 28, 2009
lata is overrated. she had an exquisite voice, but could never manage much
intensity of expression. geeta dutt makes every word throb with meaning.
the only other singer who could that was kl saigal.

jayabn on September 07, 2009
so cuTe song...

jayabn on September 07, 2009
1 of geeta dutt'z best evva...

Talat991 on September 07, 2009
Kya gana hai, kya awaaz hai! kya music hai! wonder why they dont make such music these days!